During lockdown, many companies transitioned to a work from home format and have chosen to continue this practice after lockdown. Employees have also continually resisted any return to in-person work policies. Due to the sudden shift, employees and employers may wonder whether working from home affects employee and employer rights. This article will aim to explore concerns regarding, time theft, right to privacy, right to disconnect, and the right to refuse to return to in-person work.

What is Time Theft?

Time theft is when employees are paid for time that they did not work. Employers should be aware that time theft has become a rising concern, as demonstrated in Besse v. Reach CPA Inc. 

In that case, Ms. Besse worked from home as an accountant at Reach CPA Inc. (Reach) from October 2021 to March 2022. However, she was terminated when Reach found 50.76 unaccounted hours on her timesheet which did not align with the data recorded by TimeCamp, a time-tracking program that was installed according to work policy on her work laptop. Upon termination, she brought a claim for unpaid wages and severance pay, but was met with a counterclaim by Reach. They argued that Ms. Besse was not entitled to additional wages or severance pay because she committed time theft. The Court found that Reach had just cause to terminate Ms. Besse and that she had to pay Reach $2,603.07 in debt and damages for time theft. 

Since courts have previously endorsed the reliability of time-tracking software to differentiate personal and work activities, employees should consider keeping their own personal record when anticipating a dispute over hours worked. 

What is the Right to Disconnect?

When working from home, the line between personal and work time becomes blurry for many. To help employees draw a clearer line, the Working for Workers Act (“the Act”) enacted in 2021 by the Province of Ontario, requires employers with 25 or more employees to have a written policy regarding the right to disconnect for all employees. This means that employees have the right to know when they are expected to work and when they can stop engaging in emails, phone calls, video calls, etc.

There has been an increase in the installation of time-tracking programs such as TimeCamp, on work laptops to help track productivity. These programs record how long a document is open, whether a streaming service is open, etc. As some employees might find these programs intrusive, the Act requiresOntario employers with 25 or more employees to have an electronic monitoring policy and disclose the usage of these programs to their staff. 

As seen in Besse, since Ms. Besse was aware that TimeCamp was being installed,the Court made no comments about privacy in regards to time-tracking software. However, if she had not been made aware of TimeCamp, her employer would have been breaching their legal obligations. 

Can I Refuse to Return to In-Person Work? 

Employers have the right to determine where employees can and cannot work but there are instances where employees can refuse to return to in-person work. Under the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act, employers have an obligation to create a safe workplace, such as post-pandemic precautions. If they fail to meet this obligation, an employee can refuse to return to in-person work. 

Additionally, depending on the employment contract signed, an employee may not be required to return to work in-person. For example, if an employee was hired for a full time remote position or made an agreement to transition to fully remote work with the employer, the employee may refuse to return to work in-person as it would be a fundamental breach of their contract. Employers are responsible for accommodating health concerns and childcare responsibilities up to the point of undue hardship. However, this does not mean limitless accommodations. 

As experts in employment law, we often advise our employers and employees with regard to the enforceability and potential liabilities of their employment agreement. Employers and employees may contact us at any time regarding their employment contract questions and needs.